Chelonoidis nigra

Galapagos turtle, Chelonoidis nigra (Geochelone nigra, also known as Geochelone elephantopus), Photo: Michael Lahanas

Superregnum: Eukaryota
Supergroup: Opisthokonta
Regnum: Animalia
Subregnum: Eumetazoa
Cladus: Bilateria
Cladus: Nephrozoa
Cladus: Deuterostomia
Phylum: Chordata
Subphylum: Vertebrata
Infraphylum: Gnathostomata
Superclassis: Tetrapoda
Classis: Reptilia
Subclassis: Anapsida
Ordo: Testudines
Subordo: Cryptodira
Superfamilia: Testudinoidea
Familia: Testudinidae
Genus: Chelonoidis
Species: Chelonoidis nigra
Subspecies: C. n. abingdoni - C. n. becki - C. n. chathamensis - C. n. darwini - C. n. ephippium - C. n. guntheri - C. n. hoodensis - C. n. microphyes - C. n. porteri - C. n. vandenburghi - C. n. vicina

Name

Chelonoidis nigra (Quoy& Gaimard, 1824)

Synonyms

* Testudo nigra
* Testudo elephantopus
* Geochelone nigra
* Geochelone elephantopus
* Chelonoidis elephantopus

References

* [1] Listed animal in CITES Appendix I

Vernacular names
Internationalization
English: Galapagos tortoise
한국어: 갈라파고스땅거북
Português: Tartaruga-gigante-de-Galápagos
中文: 加拉帕戈斯象龜

The Galápagos tortoise or Galápagos giant tortoise (Chelonoidis nigra) is the largest living species of tortoise, reaching weights of over 400 kg (880 lb) and lengths of over 1.8 meters (6 ft). With life spans in the wild of over 100 years, it is one of the longest lived vertebrates. A captive individual lived at least 170 years.

The tortoise is native to seven of the Galápagos Islands, a volcanic archipelago about 1,000 km (620 mi) west of Ecuador. Spanish explorers who discovered the islands in the 16th century named them after the Spanish "galápago", meaning tortoise.

Shell size and shape vary between populations. On islands with humid highlands, the tortoises are larger, with domed shells and short necks. On islands with dry lowlands, the tortoises are smaller, with 'saddleback' shells and long necks. These island to island differences played a role in the inception of Charles Darwin's theory of evolution.

Tortoise numbers declined from over 250,000 in the 16th century to a low of around 3,000 in the 1970s. The decline was caused by hunting for tortoise meat and oil, habitat clearance for agriculture, and introduction of non-native animals such as rats, goats, and pigs. Seven subspecies of the original ten survive in the wild. An eighth subspecies (C. n. abingdoni) has only a single living individual, in captivity, nicknamed Lonesome George. Conservation efforts beginning in the 20th century have resulted in thousands of captive-bred juveniles being released onto their home islands, and it is estimated that numbers exceeded 19,000 at the start of the 21st century. Despite this rebound, the species as a whole is classified as 'Vulnerable' by the IUCN.

Taxonomy

Early classification

The Galápagos Islands were discovered in 1535, but first appeared on maps, of Gerardus Mercator and Abraham Ortelius, in about 1570.[21] The islands were named "Insulae de los Galopegos" (Islands of the Tortoises) in reference to the giant tortoises found there.[10][22][23][nb 1]

Initially, the giant tortoises of the Indian Ocean and those from the Galápagos were considered to be the same species. Naturalists thought that sailors had transported the tortoises.[24] In 1676, the pre-Linnaean authority Claude Perrault referred to both species as Tortue des Indes.[25] In 1783, Johann Gottlob Schneider classified all giant tortoises as Testudo indica ("indian tortoise").[26] In 1812, August Friedrich Schweigger named them Testudo gigantea ("gigantic tortoise").[27] But, in 1834, André Marie Constant Duméril and Gabriel Bibron classified the Galápagos tortoises as a separate species, which they named Testudo nigrita ("black tortoise").[13]
Black and white photograph of Walter Rothschild straddling an adult Galápagos tortoise. Rothschild is a Victorian gentleman sporting a beard and top hat.
Walter Rothschild, cataloguer of two Galápagos tortoise subspecies

Recognition of subpopulations

The first systematic survey of giant tortoises was by Albert Günther of the British Museum, in 1875.[9] Günther identified at least five distinct populations from the Galápagos, and three from the Indian Ocean islands. He expanded the list in 1877 to six from the Galápagos, four from the Seychelles, and four from the Mascarenes.

Günther theorised that all the giant tortoises descended from a single ancestral population which spread by sunken land bridges.[4] This theory was later disproven by the understanding that the Galápagos, Seychelles and Mascarene islands are all of recent volcanic origin. They could not have been linked by land bridges. It is now thought that the Galápagos tortoises descended from an ancestor from South America.[28] The Indian Ocean tortoises derived from Madagascar.[29][30]

At the end of the 19th century, Georg Baur[31] and Walter Rothschild[5][8][19] recognized five more populations of Galápagos tortoise. In 1906, the Academy of Sciences collected specimens and gave them to John Van Denburgh for study. He identified four additional populations,[6] and proposed the existence of 15 species.[32] His list still guides the taxonomy of the Galápagos tortoise, though with modifications.[2]

Current species and genus names

The current species designation of nigra ("black" – Quoy & Gaimard, 1824b[3]) was resurrected in 1984,[33] after it was discovered to be the senior synonym (an older taxonomic synonym taking historical precedence) for the then commonly used species name of elephantopus ("elephant footed" – Harlan, 1827[12]). The use of nigra is explained by Quoy and Gaimard's description: "Testudo toto corpore nigro", meaning "tortoise with completely black body". Quoy and Gairmard described nigra from a living specimen, but there is no evidence that they knew of its accurate provenence within the Galápagos – the locality was in fact given as California. Garman (1917) proposed the linking of nigra with the extinct Floreana subspecies. Later, Pritchard (1996) deemed it was convenient to accept this account despite its tenuousness because this decision allowed minimal disruption to the already-confused nomenclature of the subspecies. The even more senior species synonym of californiana ("californian" – Quoy & Gaimard, 1824a[11]) is considered a nomen oblitum ("forgotten name").[10]

Previously, the Galápagos tortoise was considered to belong to the genus Geochelone known as typical tortoises or terrestrial turtles. Subsequently, subgenus Chelonoidis was elevated to generic status based on phylogenetic evidence which grouped the South American members of Geochelone into an independent clade (branch of the tree of life).[34] This nomenclature has been adopted by several authorities.[1][2][35][36]

Subspecies

Main article: Subspecies of Galápagos tortoise

There were probably 10 subspecies of Chelonoidis nigra, although some recognise up to 15 subspecies.[37] Only seven subspecies now exist in the wild, one on Santiago, Santa Cruz, San Cristóbal, Pinzón and Española, and two on Isabela. An eighth surviving subspecies, abingdoni from Pinta Island, is considered extinct in the wild and is represented by a single living specimen, 'Lonesome George'. The subspecies inhabiting Floreana island (C. n. nigra) is thought to have been hunted to extinction by 1850,[38][39] only years after Charles Darwin's landmark visit of 1835 in which he saw shells but no live tortoises on the island.[40] The phantastica subspecies of Fernandina is of disputed existence as it was described from a single specimen which may have been an artificial introduction to the island.[10][41][42]

Prior to widespread knowledge of the differences between the populations (sometimes called 'races') from different islands and volcanoes, captive collections in zoos were indiscriminately mixed. Fertile offspring resulted from pairings of animals from different races, confirming that they are subspecies and not distinct species. However captive crosses between tortoises from different races have lower fertility and higher mortality than those between tortoises of the same race[43][44] and captives in mixed herds normally direct courtship only toward members of the same race.[44]

The valid scientific names of each the individual populations are not universally accepted,[10][41][45][46] and some researchers consider each subspecies to be a full species.[47][48] The taxonomic status of the various races is not fully resolved.[49]

Evolutionary history

All subspecies of Galápagos tortoise evolved from common ancestors that arrived from mainland South America by overwater dispersal. The minimal founding population was a pregnant female or a breeding pair.[28] Survival on the 1000 km oceanic journey is accounted for by the fact that the tortoises are buoyant, can breathe by extending their necks above the water, and are able to survive months without food or fresh water. As they are poor swimmers, the journey was probably a passive one facilitated by the Humboldt Current, which diverts westwards towards the Galápagos Islands from the mainland.[37]

The closest living relative (though not a direct ancestor) of the Galápagos giant tortoise is the Argentine Tortoise (Chelonoidis chilensis), a much smaller species from South America. The divergence between C. chilensis and C. nigra probably occurred 6–12 million years ago, an evolutionary event preceding the volcanic formation of the oldest modern Galápagos Islands 5 million years ago.[50] Mitochondrial DNA analysis indicates that the oldest existing islands (Española and San Cristóbal) were colonised first, and that these populations seeded the younger islands via dispersal in a 'stepping stone' fashion via local currents.[51][52] Restricted gene flow between isolated islands then resulted in the independent evolution of the populations into the divergent forms observed in the modern subspecies. The evolutionary relationships between the subspecies thus echoes the volcanic history of the islands.[28]

Subspecies genetics

Modern DNA methods have revealed new information on the relationships between the subspecies:

Isabela Island

A distinct population was once thought to inhabit each of the five main volcanoes of the largest island Isabela: (Wolf, Darwin, Alcedo, Sierra Negra, and Cerro Azul). The four southern populations on Isabela, though separated from each other by barren stretches of lava between volcanoes, are in fact a single genetic unit derived from colonists from Santa Cruz. The genetically distinct Volcán Wolf subspecies in northern Isabela (becki) is probably the result of a separate colonisation event from Santiago.[28] Tortoises from Sierra Negra in southern Isabela (formerly guentheri) are possibly the ancestral source of dispersal to the volcanoes Darwin (formely microphyes), Alcedo (formerly vandenburghi) and Cerro Azul (vicina).[53] On this basis the southern populations on Isabela may be considered as a single subspecies vicina, with morphological differences attributable to age, sex or local environment.[10]

Floreana Island

Phylogenetic analysis may help to 'resurrect' the extinct subspecies of Floreana (nigra). The subspecies was only known from subfossil remains.[39] Some tortoises from Isabela were found to be a partial match for the genetic profile of Floreana specimens from museum collections, possibly indicating the presence of hybrids from a population transposed by humans from Floreana to Isabela[48] either by deliberate moving between the islands[10] or from individuals thrown overboard ships to lighten loads.[31] Nine Floreana descendants have been identified in the captive population of the Fausto Llerena Breeding Center on Santa Cruz. This permits the possibility of re-establishing a reconstructed subspecies from selective breeding of the hybrid animals.[54]

Pinta Island

The Pinta Island subspecies (abingdoni, now extinct in the wild) is most closely related to the subspecies on the islands of San Cristóbal (chathamensis) and Española (hoodensis) which lie over 300 km away,[28] rather than neighbouring Isabela as previously assumed. This relationship is attributable to dispersal by the strong local current from San Cristóbal towards Pinta.[55] The discovery informed further attempts for the preservation of the abingdoni lineage and the search for an appropriate mate for Lonesome George, who had been penned with females from Isabela.[56] This hope was bolstered by the discovery of an abingdoni hybrid male in the Volcán Wolf population on northern Isabela, raising the possibility that there are more living undiscovered Pinta descendants.[57]

Santa Cruz Island

Mitochondrial DNA studies of tortoises on Santa Cruz show up to three genetically distinct lineages found in non-overlapping population distributions around the regions of Cerro Monturra, Cerro Fatal and La Caseta.[58] Although currently united in a single subspecies (porteri), the lineages are all more closely related to tortoises on other islands than to each other;[59] Cerro Monturra tortoises are most closely related to duncanensis from Pinzón, Cerro Fatal to chathamensis from San Cristóbal, and La Caseta to the four southern races of Isabela.[60]

Subspecies of doubtful existence

Subspecies were described from three other islands, but their existence is based on scant evidence. The purported Rabida island subspecies (wallacei) was described from a single specimen removed by the Academy of Sciences in 1906,[32] which has since been lost. This individual was probably an artificial introduction from another island that was originally penned on Rabida next to a good anchorage, as no contemporary whaling or sealing logs mention removing tortoises from this island.[10][42] The phantastica subspecies from Fernandina is known from a single specimen from the voyage of 1906, an old male.[32] No other tortoises or remains have been found on the island, suggesting the specimen was an artificial introduction from elsewhere.[10][41][42] Fernandina has neither human settlements nor feral mammals, so if this subspecies ever did exist its extinction must have been by natural means, such as volcanic activity.[41] The Santa Fe subspecies has no binomial name, having been described from the limited evidence of bone fragments (but no shells, the most durable part) of 14 individuals, old eggs and old dung found on the island in 1906.[32] The island has never been inhabited by man nor had any introduced predators.[10] The remains are considered artificial introductions,[41] possibly from camping at the good anchorage on the island.[10]

Description

The tortoises have a large bony shell (carapace) of a dull brown colour. The plates of the carapace are fused with the ribs in a rigid protective structure that is integral to the skeleton. Lichen can grow on the shells of the slow-moving animals.[61] Tortoises keep a characteristic scute (shell segment) pattern on their shell throughout life, though the annual growth bands are not useful for aging as the outer layers are worn off with time. A tortoise can withdraw its head, neck and forelimbs into its shell for protection. The legs are large and stumpy, with dry scaly skin and hard scales. The front legs are five-clawed, and the back legs are four-clawed.[32]

Gigantism

The discoverer of the Galápagos Islands, Fray Tomás de Berlanga, Bishop of Panama, wrote in 1535 of "such big tortoises that each could carry a man on top of himself."[62] Naturalist Charles Darwin remarked after his trip exactly three centuries later in 1835, "These animals grow to an immense size ... several so large that it required six or eight men to lift them from the ground".[63] The largest recorded individuals have reached weights of over 400 kilograms (882 lb)[64] and lengths of 1.87 meters (6 ft).[65] The tortoises' gigantism was probably a preadapted condition for successful colonisation of these remote oceanic islands rather than an example of evolved insular gigantism. Large tortoises would have a greater chance of surviving the journey over water from the mainland as they can hold their heads a greater height above the water level and have a surface area/volume ratio reducing osmotic water loss. Their significant water and fat reserves would allow the tortoises to survive long ocean crossings without food or fresh water, and to endure the drought-prone climate of the islands. A larger size allowed them to better tolerate extremes of temperature due to gigantothermy.[10] Fossil giant tortoises from mainland South America have been described which support this hypothesis of preadapted gigantism.[66]

Shell shape

Galápagos tortoise shell varieties
A tortoise of the chathamensis subspecies. It has a slightly saddle shaped shell.
Intermediate (chathamensis)
A tortoise of the porteri subspecies. It has a rounded shell shaped like a dome.
Domed (porteri)

Galapágos tortoises are the only lineage of giant tortoise exhibiting different types of shell shape.[59] They exhibit a spectrum of carapace morphology from 'saddleback' (denoting upward arching of the front edge of the shell resembling a saddle) to 'domed' (denoting a rounded convex surface resembling a dome). When saddleback tortoises withdraw their head and forelimbs into their shells a large unprotected gap remains over their neck, evidence of the lack of predation during the evolution of this structure. There is no saddleback/domed dualism, as tortoises can be of intermediate type with characteristics of both. Larger islands with humid highlands over 800 m in elevation, such as Santa Cruz have abundant vegetation near the ground.[46] Native tortoises in these environments tend to have domed shells and are larger, with shorter necks and limbs. Saddleback tortoises originate from small islands less than 500 m in elevation with dry habitats (e.g. Española and Pinzón) that are more limited in food and other resources.[37]

Evolutionary implications

In combination with proportionally longer necks and limbs,[32] the unusual saddleback carapace structure is thought to be an adaptation to increase vertical reach, which enables the tortoise to browse tall vegetation, such as the Opuntia (prickly pear) cactus which grows in arid environments.[67] Saddlebacks are more territorial[65][68] and smaller than domed varieties, possibly adaptations to their limited resources. Alternatively, larger tortoises may be better suited to high elevations, because they can resist the cooler temperatures when there is cloud cover or fog.[45]

A competing hypothesis is that rather than being principally a feeding adaptation, the distinctive saddle shape and longer extremities might have been a secondary sexual characteristic of saddleback males. Male competition over mates is settled by dominance displays on the basis of vertical neck height rather than body size[45] (see below). This correlates with the observation that saddleback males are more aggressive than domed males.[69] The shell distortion and elongation of the limbs and neck in saddlebacks is probably the evolutionary compromise between the need for a small body size in dry conditions and a high vertical reach for dominance displays.[45]

The saddleback carapace probably evolved independently several times in dry habitats,[65] since genetic similarity between populations does not correspond to carapace shape.[70] Saddleback tortoises are therefore not necessarily more closely related to each other than to domed counterparts, as shape is not determined by a similar genetic background, but by a similar ecological one.[45]

Sexual dimorphism

Sexual dimorphism is most pronounced in saddleback populations, in which males have more angled and higher front openings, giving a more extreme saddled appearance.[69] Males of all varieties generally have a longer tail and a shorter, concave undershell with thickened knobs at the back edge to facilitate mating. Males are larger than females: adult males weigh around 272–317 kilograms (600–700 lb) whilst females are 136–181 kilograms (300–400 lb).[45]

Behaviour

Routine

The tortoises are ectothermic (cold-blooded) and therefore bask for 1–2 hours after dawn to absorb the sun's heat through their dark shells before actively foraging for 8–9 hours a day.[41] They travel mostly in the early morning or late afternoon between resting and grazing areas. They have been observed to walk at a speed of 0.3 kilometres per hour (0.19 mph).[63] On the larger and more humid islands, the tortoises seasonally migrate down between low elevations, which become grassy plains in the wet season, to meadowed areas of higher elevation (up to 2,000 ft[32]) in the dry season. The same routes have been used for many generations, creating well-defined paths through the undergrowth known as 'tortoise highways'.[46] On these wetter islands, the domed tortoises are gregarious and often found in large herds, in contrast to the more solitary and territorial disposition of the saddleback tortoises.

Tortoises sometimes rest in mud wallows or rain-formed pools, which may be both a thermoregulatory response during cool nights, and a protection from parasites such as mosquitoes and ticks.[46] Parasites are countered by taking dust baths in loose soil. Tortoises have been noted to shelter at night under overhanging rocks.[71] Other tortoises are observed to sleep in a snug depression in the earth or brush called a 'pallet'. Local tortoises using the same pallet sites, such as on Volcán Alcedo, results in the formation of small sandy pits.[72]

Diet

An adult tortoise with a mouthful of green leaves.
A tortoise feeding.

The tortoises are herbivores that consume a diet of cactus, grasses, leaves, lichen, and berries. They have been documented to feed on Hippomane mancinella ('poison apple'), the endemic guava Psidium galapageium, the water fern Azolla microphylla, and the bromeliad Tillandsia insularis.[73] A tortoise eats an average of 70–80 pounds (32–36 kg) per day, though inefficient digestion means that much of this passes through without nutritional extraction.[74]

Tortoises acquire most of their moisture from the dew and sap in vegetation (particularly the Opuntia cactus); therefore, they can spend long periods without drinking water. They can endure 18 months when deprived of all food and water,[75] surviving by breaking down their body fat to produce water as a by-product. When thirsty they may drink large quantities of water very quickly, storing it in their bladders and the 'root of the neck' (the pericardium[41]), both of which used to make them useful water sources on ships.[75] On arid islands, tortoises lick morning dew from boulders, and the repeated action over many generations has formed half-sphere depressions in the rock.[41]

Senses

Regarding their senses, Charles Darwin observed that: "The inhabitants believe that these animals are absolutely deaf; certainly they do not overhear a person walking near behind them. I was always amused, when overtaking one of these great monsters as it was quietly pacing along, to see how suddenly, the instant I passed, it would draw in its head and legs, and uttering a deep hiss fall to the ground with a heavy sound, as if struck dead".[63] Although they are not deaf,[32] tortoises depend far more on vision and smell as stimuli.[46]

Mutualism

Tortoises share a mutualistic relationship with some species of Galápagos finch and mockingbirds. Small groups of finches initiate the process by hopping on the ground in an exaggerated fashion facing the tortoise. The tortoise signals it is ready by rising up and extending its neck and legs, enabling the birds to reach otherwise inaccessible spots on the tortoise's body such as the neck, rear legs, cloacal opening, and skin between plastron and carapace. The birds benefit from the food source and the tortoises get rid of irritating ecto-parasites.[76]

Some tortoises have been observed to insidiously exploit this mutualistic relationship. After rising and extending its limbs, the bird may go beneath the tortoise to investigate, whereupon suddenly the tortoise withdraws its limbs to drop flat and kill the bird. It then steps back to eat the bird, presumably to supplement its diet with protein.[77]

Mating

Mating occurs at any time of the year, although it does have seasonal peaks between February and June in the humid uplands during the rainy season.[46] When mature males meet in the mating season they will face each other in a ritualised dominance display, rise up on their legs and stretch up their necks with their mouths gaping open. Occasionally, head-biting occurs, but usually the shorter tortoise will back off, conceding mating rights to the victor. The behaviour is most pronounced in saddleback subspecies, which are more aggressive and have longer necks.[69]

The prelude to mating can be very aggressive, as the male forcefully rams the female's shell with his own and nips her legs.[20] Mounting is an awkward process and the male must stretch and tense to maintain equilibrium in a slanting position. The concave underside of the male's shell helps him to balance when straddled over the female's shell, and brings his cloacal vent (which houses the penis) closer to the female's dilated cloaca. During mating, the male vocalises with hoarse bellows and grunts,[71] described as 'rhythmic groans'.[46] This is one of the few vocalisations the tortoise makes; other noises are made during aggressive encounters, when struggling to right themselves, and hissing as they withdraw into their shells due to the forceful expulsion of air.[78]

Egg-laying

Females then journey up to several kilometres in July to November to reach nesting areas of dry, sandy coast. Nest digging is a tiring and elaborate task which may take the female several hours a day over many days to complete.[46] It is carried out blindly using only the hind legs to dig a 30 cm (12 in) deep cylindrical hole, into which she lays up to sixteen spherical, hard-shelled eggs ranging from 82 to 157 g in mass,[41] and the size of a billiard ball.[61] Some observations suggest that the average clutch size for domed populations (9.6 per clutch for porteri on Santa Cruz) is larger than that of saddlebacks (4.6 per clutch for duncanensis on Pinzón).[42] The female makes a muddy plug for the nest hole out of soil mixed with urine, seals the nest by pressing down firmly with her plastron, and leaves them to be incubated by the sun. Females may lay 1–4 clutches per season. Temperature plays a role in the sex of the hatchling, with lower temperature nests producing more males and higher temperature nests producing more females. This is related closely to incubation time, since clutches laid early will incubate during the cool season and have longer incubation periods (producing more males), while nests that are laid later incubate for a shorter period in the hot season (producing more females).[79]

Early life and maturation

Young animals emerge from the nest after 4 to 8 months and may weigh only 50 grams (1.8 oz) and measure 6 centimetres (2.4 in).[46] When the young tortoises emerge from their shells, they must dig their way to the surface, which can take up several weeks, though their yolk sac can sustain them for up to seven months.[61] In particularly dry conditions, the hatchlings may die underground if they are encased by hardened soil, while flooding of the nest area can drown them. Subspecies are initially indistinguishable as they all have domed carapaces. The young stay in warmer lowland areas for the their first 10–15 years,[41] encountering hazards such as falling into cracks, being crushed by falling rock, or excessive heat stress. The Galápagos Hawk was formerly the sole native predator of the tortoise hatchlings, as Darwin wrote: "The young tortoises, as soon as they are hatched, fall prey in great numbers to the buzzard".[63] The hawk is now much rarer, but introduced feral pigs, dogs, cats and black rats have become predators of eggs and young tortoises.[80] The adult tortoises have no natural predators apart from humans, as Darwin noted: "The old ones seem generally to die from accidents, as from falling down precipices. At least several of the inhabitants told me, they had never found one dead without some such apparent cause".[63]

Sex can be determined only when the tortoise is about 15 years old, and sexual maturity is reached at around 20–25 in captivity, possibly 40 years in the wild (when they reach their full size). Life expectancy in the wild is thought to be over 100 years,[81][82] making it one of the longest lived species in the animal kingdom. Harriet was the oldest known Galápagos tortoise, having reached an estimated age of more than 170 years before her death in 2006 in Australia Zoo.[83]
[edit] Darwin's development of theory of evolution

Charles Darwin visited the Galápagos for five weeks on the second voyage of HMS Beagle in 1835 and saw Galápagos tortoises on San Cristobal (Chatham) and Santiago (James) Islands.[84] They appeared several times in his writings and journals, and played a role in the development of the theory of evolution.

Recognition of subpopulations

Darwin wrote is his account of the voyage:

"I have not as yet noticed by far the most remarkable feature in the natural history of this archipelago; it is, that the different islands to a considerable extent are inhabited by a different set of beings. My attention was first called to this fact by the Vice-Governor, Mr. Lawson, declaring that the tortoises differed from the different islands, and that he could with certainty tell from which island any one was brought ... The inhabitants, as I have said, state that they can distinguish the tortoises from the different islands; and that they differ not only in size, but in other characters. Captain Porter has described* those from Charles and from the nearest island to it, namely, Hood Island, as having their shells in front thick and turned up like a Spanish saddle, whilst the tortoises from James Island are rounder, blacker, and have a better taste when cooked."[85]

The significance of the differences in tortoises between islands did not strike him as important until it was too late, as he continued,

"I did not for some time pay sufficient attention to this statement, and I had already partially mingled together the collections from two of the islands. I never dreamed that islands, about fifty or sixty miles apart, and most of them in sight of each other, formed of precisely the same rocks, placed under a quite similar climate, rising to a nearly equal height, would have been differently tenanted".[85]

Loss of specimens

Although the Beagle departed from the Galápagos with over 30 adult tortoises on deck, these were not for scientific study but a source of fresh meat for their Pacific crossing. Their shells and bones were thrown overboard, leaving no remains with which to test any hypotheses.[86] It has been suggested[87] that this oversight was made because Darwin only reported seeing tortoises on San Cristóbal[88] (chathamensis) and Santiago[89] (darwini), both of which have an intermediate type of shell shape and are not particularly morphologically distinct from each other. Though he did visit Floreana, the nigra subspecies found there was already nearly extinct and he was unlikely to have seen any mature animals.[10]

Return from the voyage

Darwin did however have four live juvenile specimens to compare from different islands. These were pet tortoises taken by himself (from San Salvador), his captain Fitzroy (two from Española) and his servant Syms Covington (from Floreana).[90] Unfortunately they could not help to determine whether each island had its own variety because the specimens were not mature enough to exhibit morphological differences.[91] Although the British Museum had a few specimens, their provenance within the Galápagos was unknown.[4] However, conversations with the naturalist Gabriel Bibron, who had seen the mature tortoises of the Paris Natural History Museum confirmed to Darwin that there were distinct varieties.[92]

Thoughts on the stability of species

Darwin later compared the different tortoise forms with those of mockingbirds, in the first[93] tentative statement linking his observations from the Galapagos with the possibility of species transmuting:

"When I recollect the fact that [from] the form of the body, shape of scales and general size, the Spaniards can at once pronounce from which island any tortoise may have been brought; when I see these islands in sight of each other and possessed of but a scanty stock of animals, tenanted by these birds, but slightly differing in structure and filling the same place in nature; I must suspect they are only varieties ... If there is the slightest foundation for these remarks, the zoology of archipelagoes will be well worth examining; for such facts would undermine the stability of species."[94]

His views on the mutability of species were restated in his notebooks:

"animals on separate islands ought to become different if kept long enough apart with slightly differing circumstances. – Now Galapagos Tortoises, Mocking birds, Falkland Fox, Chiloe fox, – Inglish and Irish Hare."[95]

These observations served as counterexamples to the prevailing contemporary view that species were individually created.

Darwin found these "antediluvian animals"[88] to be a source of diversion: "I frequently got on their backs, and then giving a few raps on the hinder part of their shells, they would rise up and walk away;—but I found it very difficult to keep my balance".[63]

Conservation

Several waves of human exploitation of the tortoises as a food source caused a decline in the total wild population from around 250,000[82] when first discovered in the 16th century to a low of 3,060 individuals in a 1974 census. Modern conservation efforts have subsequently brought tortoise numbers up to 19,317 (estimate for 1995–2009).[96]

The subspecies C. n. nigra became extinct by human exploitation in the 19th century. Another subspecies, C. n. abingdoni, is now extinct in the wild and represented in captivity by a single male specimen, Lonesome George. It is the only known living specimen of the Pinta Island tortoise and the world's "rarest living creature".[97] All the other surviving subspecies are listed by the IUCN as at least 'Vulnerable' in conservation status, if not worse.

Historical exploitation

An estimated 200,000 animals were taken before the 20th century.[10][41] The relatively immobile and defenceless tortoises were collected and stored live on board ships, where they could survive for at least a year without food or water (some anecdotal reports suggest individuals surviving two years[98]), providing valuable fresh meat, whilst their diluted urine and water stored in their neck bags could be used as drinking water. The 17th century British pirate, explorer and naturalist William Dampier wrote that 'They are so extraordinarily large and fat, and so sweet, that no pullet eats more pleasantly,'[99] whilst Captain James Colnett of the British Navy wrote of "the land tortoise which in whatever way it was dressed, was considered by all of us as the most delicious food we had ever tasted."[100] US Navy captain David Porter declared that, "after once tasting the Gallipagos tortoises, every other animal food fell off greatly in our estimation ... The meat of this animal is the easiest of digestion, and a quantity of it, exceeding that of any other food, can be eaten without experiencing the slightest of inconvenience."[75] Darwin was less enthusiastic about tortoise meat, writing "the breast-plate roasted (as the Gauchos do "carne con cuero"), with the flesh on it, is very good; and the young tortoises make excellent soup; but otherwise the meat to my taste is indifferent."[101]

In the 17th century, pirates started to use the Galápagos Islands as a base for resupply, restocking on food, water and repairing vessels before attacking Spanish colonies on the South American mainland. However, the Galápagos tortoises did not struggle for survival at this point because the islands were distant to busy shipping routes and harboured few valuable natural resources. As such they remained unclaimed by any nation, uninhabited and uncharted. In comparison, the tortoises of the islands in the Indian Ocean were already facing extinction by the late 17th century.[102]

Between the 1790s and the 1860s, whaling ships and fur-sealers systematically collected tortoises in far greater numbers than the buccaneers preceding them.[103] They were used for food and many more were killed for high grade 'turtle oil' from the late 19th century onward for lucrative sale to continental Ecuador.[104] A total of over 13,000 tortoises is recorded in the logs of whaling ships between 1831 and 1868, and an estimated 100,000 were taken before 1830.[98] Since it was easiest to collect tortoises around coastal zones, females were most vulnerable to depletion during the nesting season. The collection by whalers came to a halt eventually through a combination of the scarcity of tortoises that they had created and the competition from crude oil as a cheaper energy source.[105]

Population decline accelerated with the early settlement of the islands in the early 19th century leading to unregulated hunting for meat, habitat clearance for agriculture and the introduction of alien mammal species.[42] Feral pigs, dogs, cats and black rats have become predators of eggs and young tortoises, whilst goats, donkeys and cattle compete for grazing and trample nest sites. The extinction of the Floreana subspecies in the mid-19th century has been attributed to the combined pressures of hunting for the penal colony on the relatively small island, the conversion of the grazing highlands into land for farming and fruit plantations, and the introduction of feral mammals.[106]

Scientific collection expeditions took 661 tortoises between 1888 and 1930, and more than 120 tortoises have been taken by poachers since 1990. Threats continue today with the rapid expansion of the tourist industry and increasing size of human settlements on the islands.[107]

Modern conservation

The remaining subspecies of tortoise range in IUCN classification from extinct in the wild to vulnerable. Slow growth rate, late sexual maturity and island endemism make the tortoises particularly prone to extinction without the efforts of conservationists.[59] The Galápagos giant tortoise has become a flagship species for conservation efforts throughout the Galápagos.
Two Galápagos tortoises occupy the foreground, apparently unconcerned by the presence of several tourists a few feet behind them. The tourists wear assorted sunglasses and sunhats, and most are taking pictures of the tortoises with their digital cameras.
Tourists see tortoises at the Charles Darwin Research station.

Legal protection

The Galápagos giant tortoise is now strictly protected and is listed on Appendix I of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora.[36] The listing requires that trade in the taxon and its products is subject to strict regulation by ratifying states and international trade for primarily commercial purposes is prohibited. In 1936 the Ecuadorian government listed the giant tortoise as a protected species. In 1959, it declared all uninhabited areas in the Galápagos to be a National Park[108] and established the Charles Darwin Foundation. In 1970, capturing or removing many species from the islands (including tortoises and their eggs) was banned.[109] To halt trade in the tortoises altogether, it became illegal to export the tortoises from Ecuador, captive or wild, continental or insular in provenance. The banning of their exportation resulted in automatic prohibition of importation to the United States under Public Law 91-135 (1969).[110] A 1971 Ecuadorian decree made it illegal to damage, remove, alter or disturb any organism, rock or other natural object in the National Park.[111]

Captive breeding

Breeding and releasing programs began in 1965 and have successfully brought 7 of the 8 endangered subspecies up to less perilous population levels. Young tortoises are raised at several breeding centres across the islands to improve their survival during their vulnerable early development. Eggs are collected from threatened nesting sites, and the hatched young are given a head start by being kept in captivity for 4 to 5 years to reach a size with a much better chance of survival to adulthood before release onto their native ranges.[80][96]

The most significant population recovery was that of the Española Tortoise (hoodensis), which was saved from near-certain extinction. The population had been depleted to 3 males and 12 females that had been so widely dispersed that no mating in the wild had occurred.[112] They were brought to the Charles Darwin Research Station in 1971 for a captive breeding program.[113] In the following 33 years, these 15 tortoises gave rise to over 1,200 tortoises released onto their home island, which themselves have begun to reproduce naturally.[10][114]

Island restoration

The Galápagos National Park Service systematically culls feral predators and competitors. Goat eradication on islands including Pinta was achieved by the technique of using 'Judas' goats with electronic collars to locate the herds. Marksmen shot all the goats except the Judas, then returned weeks later to find the 'Judas' and shoot the herd to which it had relocated, repeating until only the 'Judas' remained, which was then killed.[115] Other measures have included dog eradication from San Cristóbal, and fencing off nests to protect them from feral pigs.[80]

Efforts are now underway to repopulate islands formerly inhabited by tortoises in order to restore their ecosystems (island restoration) to their pre-human condition. The tortoises are a keystone species, acting as ecosystem engineers[115] which help in plant seed dispersal, trampling down brush and thinning the understory of vegetation (allowing light to penetrate and germination to occur). Birds such as flycatchers perch on and fly around tortoises in order to hunt the insects they displace from the brush.[61] In May 2010, 39 sterilised tortoises of hybrid origin were introduced to Pinta Island, the first tortoises there since the evacuation of Lonesome George 38 years ago in 1972.[116] Sterile tortoises were released so that the problem of interbreeding between subspecies would be avoided if any fertile tortoises were to be released in the future. It is hoped that with the recent identification of a hybrid abingdoni tortoise, the approximate genetic constitution of the original inhabitants of Pinta may eventually be restored with the identification and relocation of appropriate specimens to this island.[57] This approach may be used to 're-tortoise' Floreana in the future, since captive individuals have been found to be descended from the extinct original stock.[54]

Notes and references

Notes

1. ^ The first navigation chart showing the individual islands was done by the pirate Ambrose Cowley in 1684. He named them after fellow pirates or English noblemen. More recently, the Ecuadorian government gave most of the islands Spanish names. While the Spanish names are official, many researchers continue to use the older English names, particularly as those were the names used when Darwin visited. This article uses the Spanish island names.

Citations

1. ^ a b c Tortoise & Freshwater Turtle Specialist Group (1996) Chelonoidis nigra In: IUCN 2009. IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Version 2009.2. www.iucnredlist.org Retrieved on 2010-09-04.
2. ^ a b c d Rhodin 2010. Turtles of the World 2010 Update: Annotated Checklist of Taxonomy, Synonymy, Distribution and Conservation Status. Chelonian Research Foundation
3. ^ a b c d e Quoy and Gaimard 1824b. Sous-genre Tortue de Terre – Testudo. Brongn. Tortue Noire – Testudo nigra. N. In: M. L. de Freycinet (ed.), Voyage autour du Monde executé sur l'Uranie et la Physicienne pendent les années 1817–1820, pp. 174–175.
4. ^ a b c d Günther 1877. The gigantic land tortoises (living and extinct) in the collection of the British Museum, British Museum (Nat. Hist.), London
5. ^ a b c Rothschild 1901. On a new land-tortoise from the Galapagos Islands Novitates Zoologicae
6. ^ a b c d e f g h i Van Denburgh 1907. Preliminary descriptions of four new races of gigantic land tortoises from the Galapagos Islands Proceedings of the California Academy of Sciences, 4th ser., v. 1.
7. ^ a b c d e Garman 1917. The Galapagos tortoises. Memoirs of the Museum of Comparative Zoölogy at Harvard College., vol. XXX, no. 4
8. ^ a b c Rothschild 1903. Description of a new species of gigantic land tortoise from Indefatigable Island. Novitates Zool. 10: 119.
9. ^ a b c d e f Gunther 1875. Description of the Living and Extinct Races of Gigantic Land-Tortoises. Parts I. and II. Introduction, and the Tortoises of the Galapagos Islands, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Biological Sciences, 165, pp. 251–284
10. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p Pritchard 1996. The Galapagos tortoises: Nomenclatural and survival status. Chelonian Research Monographs. (1):1–85
11. ^ a b c Quoy and Gaimard 1824a. Description d'une nouvelle espèce de tortue et de trois espèces nouvelles de scinques. Bull. Sci. Nat. Geol., Paris: Zoologie, pp. 90–91
12. ^ a b Harlan 1827. Description of a land tortoise, from the Galápagos Islands, commonly known as the "Elephant Tortoise." Journal of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia 5: 284–292.
13. ^ a b c Duméril and Bibron 1834. Erpétologie Générale ou Histoire Naturelle Complète des Reptiles, Librarie Encyclopédique de Roret (France)
14. ^ Gray 1854. Description of a new species of tortoise (Testudo planiceps), from the Galapagos Islands. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1853[1854]:12–13.
15. ^ Williams 1952. A new fossil tortoise from Mona Island West Indies and a tentative arrangement of the tortoises of the world. Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History 99(9):541–560
16. ^ Pritchard 1967. Living Turtles of the World. TFH Publications, New Jersey p. 156
17. ^ Bour 1980. Essai sur la taxinomie des Testudinidae actuels (Reptilia, Chelonii). Bull. Mus. natl. Hist. nat. Paris (4)2:546
18. ^ a b Baur 1889. The gigantic land tortoises of the Galapagos Islands. The American Naturalist 23:1039–1057
19. ^ a b c Rothschild 1902. Description of a new species of gigantic land tortoise from the Galápagos Islands. Novitates Zoologicae 9: 619.
20. ^ a b DeSola 1930. The Liebespiel of Testudo vandenburghi, a new name for the mid-Albemarle Island Galápagos tortoise. Copeia. 1930:79–80
21. ^ Stewart, Paul D. (2006). Galápagos: the islands that changed the world. Yale University Press. p. 43. ISBN 978-0-300-12230-5.
22. ^ Jackson, Michael Hume (1993). Galápagos, a natural history. University of Calgary Press. p. 1. ISBN 978-1-895176-07-0.
23. ^ REAL ACADEMIA ESPAÑOLA, DICCIONARIO DE LA LENGUA ESPAÑOLA – Vigésima segunda edición
24. ^ Chambers 2004. A sheltered life: The Unexpected History of the Giant Tortoise. John Murray. London. ISBN 0-7195-6528-6. p. 27
25. ^ Perrault 1676. Suite des memoires pour servir a l'histoire naturelle des animaux. Paris, pp. 92–205
26. ^ Schneider 1783. Allgemeine Naturgeschischte der Schildkröten nebs einem systematischen Verzeichnisse der einzelnen Arten und zwey Kupfen. Leipzig.
27. ^ Schweigger 1812. Prodromi monographiae Chelonorum sectio prima, Köningsberg (Germany)
28. ^ a b c d e Caccone 1999. Origin and evolutionary relationships of giant Galapagos tortoises. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science. 96(23):13223-13228
29. ^ Austin and Arnold 2001. Ancient mitochondrial DNA and morphology elucidate an extinct island radiation of Indian Ocean giant tortoises (Cylindraspis) Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B, 268, pp. 2515–2523
30. ^ Austin and Arnold 2003. Was there a second adaptive radiation of giant tortoises in the Indian Ocean? Using mitochondrial DNA to investigate speciation and biogeography of Aldabrachelys Molecular Ecology, 12, pp. 1415–1424
31. ^ a b Baur 1889. The gigantic land tortoises of the Galapagos Islands. The American Naturalist 23:1039–1057
32. ^ a b c d e f g h Van Denburgh 1914. The gigantic land tortoises of the Galapagos archipelago. Proceedings of the California Academy of Sciences. Series 4, 2(1):203–374. ISBN 1-120-88514-0.
33. ^ Pritchard 1984. Further thoughts on Lonesome George. Noticias de Galápagos 39: 20–23
34. ^ Le 2006. A molecular phylogeny of tortoises (Testudines:Testudinidae) based on mitochondrial and nuclear genes. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution. 40(2):517–531
35. ^ Fritz and Havaš 2007. Checklist of Chelonians of the World. Vertebrate Zoology. 57(2):149–368
36. ^ a b CITES Appendices I, II and III 2010
37. ^ a b c Caccone 2002. Phylogeography and history of the Giant Galapagos Tortoises. Evolution. 56(10):2052–2066
38. ^ Broom 1929. On the extinct Galápagos tortoise that inhabited Charles Island. Zoologica 9:313–320.
39. ^ a b Steadman 1986. Holocene vertebrate fossils from Isla Floreana, Galápagos. Smith Contrib Zool 413:1–103
40. ^ Sulloway 1984. Darwin and the Galápagos. In: Berry, R.J. (Ed.) Evolution in the Galápagos islands. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 21(1–2):29–60.
41. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Swingland 1989. Geochelone elephantopus. Galapagos giant tortoises. In: I. R. Swingland and M. W. Klemens, (Eds.) The Conservation Biology of Tortoises. Occasional Papers of the IUCN Species Survival Commission (SSC), No. 5. pp. 24–28. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN. ISBN 2880329868.
42. ^ a b c d e MacFarland 1974a. The galapagos giant tortoises (Geochelone elephantopus). I. Status of the surviving populations. Biological Conservation. 6(2):118–133
43. ^ MacFarland 1974b. The Galápagos giant tortoises (Geochelone elephantopus). Part II: Conservation methods. Biological Conservation. 6: 198–212.
44. ^ a b Márquez 1988. Comportamiento de Apareamiento al Azar en tortugas gigantes. Juveniles en cautiverio el las Islas Galápagos. Rept. Charles Darwin Research Station Library. 1988:2–15
45. ^ a b c d e f Fritts 1984. Evolutionary divergence of giant tortoises in Galapagos. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society. 21:165–176
46. ^ a b c d e f g h i DeVries 1984. The giant tortoises: a natural history disturbed by man. In: R. Perry (Ed.) Key Environments. Galapagos, pp. 145–156. Oxford: Pergamon Press. ISBN 0-08-027996-1.
47. ^ Ernst and Barbour 1989. Turtles of the World. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution Press. ISBN 978-0-87474-414-9.
48. ^ a b Poulakakis 2008. Historical DNA analysis reveals living descendants of an extinct species of Galapagos tortoise. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 105:15464-15469
49. ^ Zug 1997. Galapagos tortoise nomenclature: still unresolved. Chelonian Conservation and Biology. 2:618–619
50. ^ White 1993. Petrology and geochemistry of the Galápagos Islands: portrait of a pathological mantle plume. Journal of Geophysical Research. 98(B11):19,533–19,564.
51. ^ Nicholls 2006. Lonesome George: The Life and Loves of a Conservation Icon. Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 1-4039-4576-4. p. 68
52. ^ Beheregaray 2004. Giant tortoises are not so slow: Rapid diversification and biogeographic consensus in the Galápagos. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 101(17):6514–6519
53. ^ Ciofi 2006. Phylogeographic History and Gene Flow Among Giant Galápagos Tortoises on Southern Isabela Island. Genetics. 172:1727–1744
54. ^ a b Russello 2010. DNA from the past informs ex situ conservation for the future: an 'extinct' species of Galapagos tortoise identified in captivity. PLoS One. 5(1):e8683
55. ^ Pak and Zaneveld 1973. The Cromwell Current on the east side of the Galapagos Islands. Journal of Geophysical Research. 78(33):7845–7859
56. ^ Nicholls 2006. Lonesome George: The Life and Loves of a Conservation Icon. Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 1-4039-4576-4. p. 161
57. ^ a b Russello 2007. Lonesome George is not alone among Galapagos tortoises. Current Biology. 17:R317–R318
58. ^ Russello 2005. A cryptic taxon of Galapagos tortoise in conservation peril. Biological Letters. 1:287–290
59. ^ a b c Chiari 2009. Morphometrics parallel genetics in a newly discovered and endangered taxon of Galapagos Tortoise. PLoS One. 4(7):e6272. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0006272
60. ^ Ciofi 2002. Microsatellite analysis of genetic divergence among populations of giant Galápagos tortoises. Molecular Ecology. 11(11):2265–2283
61. ^ a b c d MacFarland 1972. Giant tortoises, Goliaths of the Galapagos. National Geographic Magazine, May:632–649
62. ^ Berlanga 1535. Letter to His Majesty ... describing his voyage from Panamá to Puerto Viejo. In Coleccion de Documentos Ineditos relativos al Descubrimiento, Conquista y Organizacion de las Antiguas Posesiones Españolas de América y Oceania, Tomo XLI, Cuaderno II. Madrid. Imprenta de Manuel G. Hernandez (1884, pp. 538–544)
63. ^ a b c d e f Darwin 1839. Narrative of the Surveying Voyages of His Majesty's Ships Adventure and Beagle pp. 462–466.
64. ^ Ebersbach 2001. Zur Biologie und Haltung der Aldabra-Riesenschildkröte (Geochelone gigantea) und der Galapagos-Riesenschildkröte (Geochelone elephantopus) in menschlicher Obhut unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Fortpflanzung. PhD Dissertation, Tierärztliche Hochschule Hannover
65. ^ a b c Fritts 1983. Morphometrics of Galapagos tortoises: Evolutionary implications. In: R. I. Bowman, M. Berson, and A. E. Leviton eds. Patterns of Evolution in Galapagos Organisms, pp. 107–122. American Association for the Advancement of Science. ISBN 0-934394-05-9.
66. ^ Auffenberg 1971. A new fossil tortoise, with remarks on the origin of South American testudinines. Copeia. 1971(1)106
67. ^ Dawson 1966. Cacti in the Galapagos Islands, with special reference to their relations with tortoises. pp. 209–214. in Bowman, R. I., editor. (ed). The Galapagos University of California Press. Berkeley.
68. ^ de Neira and Roe 1984. Emergence success of tortoise nests and the effect of feral burros on nest success on Volcán Alcedo, Galapagos. Copeia. 1984(3):702–707
69. ^ a b c Schafer and Krekorian 1983. Agonistic behavior of the Galapagos tortoise, Geochelone elephantopus, with emphasis on its relationship to saddle-backed shell shape. Herpetologica. 39(4):448–456
70. ^ Marlow and Patton 1981. Biochemical relationships of the Galápagos Giant tortoises (Geochelone elephantopus). Journal of Zoology. 195(3):413–422
71. ^ a b Carpenter 1966. Notes on the behavior and ecology of the Galapagos tortoise on Santa Cruz Island. Proceedings of the Oklahoma Academy of Science. 46:28–32
72. ^ Jackson, Michael Hume (1993). Galápagos, a natural history. University of Calgary Press. p. 107. ISBN 978-1-895176-07-0.
73. ^ Cayot 1987. Ecology of giant tortoises (Geochelone elephantopus) in the Galápagos Islands. PhD Dissertation, Syracuse University, Syracuse, New York.
74. ^ Hatt 2005. Fiber digestibility in juvenile Galapagos tortoises (Geochelone nigra) and implications for the development of captive animals. Zoo Biology. 24(2):185–191
75. ^ a b c Porter 1815. Journal of the Cruise Made to the Pacific Ocean by Captain Porter in the United States Frigate Essex in the years 1812, 1813, 1814. 2 vols. Philadelphia. Second Edition, New York, 1822. p. 151
76. ^ MacFarland and Reeder 1974. Cleaning symbiosis involving Galápagos tortoises and two species of Darwin's finches. Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie. 34:464–483
77. ^ Bonin 2006. Turtles of the World. Peter C. H. Pritchard, (translator). Johns Hopkins University Press. ISBN 0-8018-8496-9.
78. ^ Hayes 1988. Defensive behavior in the Galapagos tortoise (Geochelone elephantopus), with comments on the evolution of insular gigantism. Herpetologica. 44(1):11–17
79. ^ Ciofi and Swingland 1997. Environmental sex determination in reptiles. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 51, 251–265.
80. ^ a b c Cayot 1994. Conservation biology of Galápagos reptiles: twenty-five years of successful research and management. In: J. B. Murphy, K. Adler, and J. T. Collins (eds.). Captive Management and Conservation of Amphibians and Reptiles, pp. 297–305. Ithaca, New York: Society for the Study of Amphibians and Reptiles. Contributions to Herpetology. vol. 11. ISBN 0-916984-33-8.
81. ^ National Geographic. Galápagos Tortoise Geochelone elephantophus. Retrieved 2010-09-04
82. ^ a b American Museum of Natural History – Giant tortoises of the Galápagos. Retrieved 2010-09-04
83. ^ Chambers 2004. The origin of Harriet 11 September 2004, New Scientist. Retrieved 2010-09-13. Chambers notes that Harriet was probably 169 years old in 2004. The individual died in 2006 (though media outlets claimed the greater age of 175 based on a less reliable timeline): Harriet the tortoise dies. 23/06/2006 ABC News Online. Retrieved 2010-09-13
84. ^ Grant, K. T and Estes, Gregory B. 2009. Darwin in Galapagos: Footsteps to a New World Princeton University Press, Princeton. ISBN 978-0-691-14210-4
85. ^ a b Darwin 1845. Journal of Researches pp. 393–394
86. ^ Chambers 2004. A sheltered life: The Unexpected History of the Giant Tortoise. John Murray. London. ISBN 0-7195-6528-6. p. 51
87. ^ Nicholls 2006. Lonesome George: The Life and Loves of a Conservation Icon. Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 1-4039-4576-4. p. 62
88. ^ a b Darwin 1839. Narrative of the surveying voyages of His Majesty's Ships Adventure and Beagle p. 456
89. ^ Keynes 2001. Charles Darwin's Beagle Diary. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0521003172. p. 362
90. ^ Chambers 2004. A sheltered life: The Unexpected History of the Giant Tortoise. John Murray. London. ISBN 0-7195-6528-6. p. 41
91. ^ Chambers 2004. A sheltered life: The Unexpected History of the Giant Tortoise. John Murray. London. ISBN 0-7195-6528-6. p. 52
92. ^ Darwin 1827; 1828–1829; 1837–1839. [Edinburgh notebook]. CUL-DAR118 p. 99v
93. ^ Chambers 2004. A sheltered life: The Unexpected History of the Giant Tortoise. John Murray. London. ISBN 0-7195-6528-6. p. 47
94. ^ Barlow ed. 1963. Darwin's Ornithological Notes Bulletin of the British Museum (Natural History). Historical Series Vol. 2, No. 7. p. 262'
95. ^ Darwin 1837–1838. Notebook B: [Transmutation of species]''. p. 7
96. ^ a b Galapagos National Park. Reproduction, breeding, repatriation, and monitoring of tortoises. Retrieved 2010-09-04.
97. ^ Footman ed. 2001 Guinness World Records. Guinness Records. ISBN 0-85112-102-0. p. 182
98. ^ a b Townsend 1925. The Galapagos tortoises in their relation to the whaling industry: a study of old logbooks. Zoologica. 4:55–135
99. ^ Dampier 1697. A New Voyage Around the World, reprinted in 1919 by Dover Publications (USA)
100. ^ Colnett 1798. A Voyage to the South Atlantic, reprinted in 1968 by Da Capo Press (USA)
101. ^ Darwin 1839. Narrative of the Surveying Voyages of His Majesty's Ships Adventure and Beagle p. 459.
102. ^ Chambers 2004. A sheltered life: The Unexpected History of the Giant Tortoise. John Murray. London. ISBN 0-7195-6528-6. p. 85
103. ^ Chambers 2004. A sheltered life: The Unexpected History of the Giant Tortoise. John Murray. London. ISBN 0-7195-6528-6. p. 94
104. ^ Beck 1903. In the home of the giant tortoise, 7th Annual Report of the New York Zoological Society New York pp. 1–17
105. ^ Chambers 2004. A sheltered life: The Unexpected History of the Giant Tortoise. John Murray. London. ISBN 0-7195-6528-6. p. 104
106. ^ Hoeck 1984. Introduced fauna. In Perry, R. (Ed.) Key Environments. Galápagos. Pergamon Press, pp. 233–245
107. ^ Watkins and Cruz 2007. Galapagos at risk: a Socioeconomic Analysis. Charles Darwin Foundation.
108. ^ Ecuador 1959. Decreto ley de emergencia, por el cual se declaran parques nacionales de reserva de exclusivo dominio del estado, para la preservación de la fauna y flora, todas las tierras que forman las islas del Archipiélago de Colón o Galápagos, Registro Oficial No. 873 (1959) Quito, 20 de Julio, 1959
109. ^ Ecuador 1970. Ley de Protección de la Fauna Silvestre y de los Recursos Ictiológicos, Registro Oficial No. 104 (1970) Quito, 20 de Noviembre 1970
110. ^ United States 1969. Endangered Species Conservation Act. 83 Stat. 275; 16 USC 668 cc-1 to 668 cc-6 (1969)
111. ^ Ecuador 1971. Decreto Supremo No. 1306 (1971) Quito, 27 de Agosto 1971
112. ^ Corley Smith 1977. The present status of the giant tortoise Geochelone elephantopus on the Galapagos Islands. International Zoo Yearbook 17:109–112
113. ^ Caporaso 1991. The Galapagos tortoise conservation program: the plight and future for the Pinzón Island tortoise. In: K. R. Beaman, F. Caporaso, S. McKeown, and M. D. Graff (eds.), Proceedings of the first International Symposium on Turtles & Tortoises: Conservation and Captive Husbandry, pp. 113–116. California: Chapman University.
114. ^ Milinkovitch 2004. Genetic analysis of a successful repatriation programme: giant Galapagos tortoises. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B. 271:341–345
115. ^ a b Carroll 27-06-2010. Galápagos giant tortoise saved from extinction by breeding programme The Observer. Retrieved 2010-09-04
116. ^ Galapagos Conservancy. Project Pinta. Retrieved 2010-09-04